Stories and rumors swirled. Who were the biggest suitors? Where would Peyton want to go? One of the rumored teams was my Washington Redskins, who were supposed to have tons of salary cap flexibility and were heavily rumored to be in pursuit with a specific plan. Peyton would even meet with head coach, Mike Shanahan. But minutes before the start of free agency, the Redskins would receive shocking news that the league was imposing a $36 million salary cap penalty. This stunning and unexpected news completely shocked the Redskins, who were bracing for a likely free agent splash, after they had cleared several million dollars of cap space the year before in the "un-capped" season. Anyway, this is a different story that I could delve into for quite some time!
It was widely believed that if not for this unexpected twist in this salary cap hit, the Redskins would have more heavily pursued Peyton. The dominoes would start to fall. Prior to the start of free agency, the Redskins would pull off the blockbuster trade with the Rams for the #2 overall pick, which of course would be used to select RG3. In fact, Peyton himself was stunned by the news, while he was meeting with John Elway. But even in this huge trade, it had been surmised that the Redskins would have still pursued the possibility of both Peyton AND Griffin. But with the cap hit, that chance went out the window. Thus, John Elway and the Denver Broncos emerged as the strongest suitor in hot pursuit. In fact, John Elway texted Mike Shanahan and asked him to "put in a good word for us", when Peyton was meeting with Mike.
Then on March 19, 2012 Peyton would agree to terms with the Broncos. In Peter King's incredible and insightful story, he documented specific details of Peyton's journey and the key moments along the way. Peyton's chapter in Denver was about to begin. Meanwhile in Indianapolis, as expected the Colts would select Andrew Luck, thus beginning their new chapter as a franchise.
So now the Peyton Manning era in Denver would begin. How would the Broncos fare, now that the new Sherriff was in town? In 2011, the Broncos would finish a mediocre 8-8 but win the division, under fan favorite QB, Tim Tebow. But even with Tim Tebow's winning success and soaring popularity, getting Peyton Manning to come to the Broncos would be a coup and there was no question that even the popular Tebow would have a short stint in Denver and have no chance of staying.
Just like he had done in Tennessee, and just like he had done with the Colts, once again Peyton's influence and leadership would lead his new team, the Broncos to new heights of greatness. Denver would soar to a league best 13-3 record and #1 seed in the playoffs. And if there were any questions about how Peyton would play on not only a different team, but most importantly coming off the several, seemingly career-ending neck surgeries, those questions were emphatically answered. Peyton would dominate, and seemingly not miss a beat from how he played all those years with the Colts. He would throw for nearly 5,000 yards, 68% completion %, 37 TD's and just 11 INT's. He took a mediocre 8 win team, a team that was offensively challenged to put it mildly, to a dominant team. But in heartbreaking fashion in the AFC divisional playoff, the heavily favored Broncos were shocked by the eventual World Champion Baltimore Ravens in a seemingly impossible scenario. The Broncos led 35-28 with 40 seconds to go, and Baltimore at their own 30 yard line. The Ravens needed a miracle, and they got it as Joe Flacco hit Jacoby Jones 50 yards down the field as the Broncos improbably and inexcusably let Jones get behind their prevent secondary for the dramatic game-tying TD. Once again, a Peyton-led team was victim to a flukish and shocking loss in the playoffs. But even with the crushing playoff loss, the 2012 season was an unbelievable success for the Broncos, and Peyton Manning.
Then in 2013, the greatness and legacy of Peyton Manning was elevated to another level. An out of this world level. Manning had arguably the greatest season not only of his career, but arguably the greatest season ever for a QB in the history of the game. All at the age of 37! Manning would pass for a league record, 5,477 yards, have a league record 55 TD's, and throw only 10 INT's. And his QB rating was a gaudy 115.1. And once again, he would lead his Broncos to a 13-3 record, runaway division championship, and another #1 seed in the playoffs. On the way to his third Super Bowl, Manning would lead the Broncos over rival Tom Brady and the Patriots in the AFC Championship game. And Peyton put up amazing numbers by completing 32-43 for an AFC Championship record 400 yards, to go along with 2 TD's, zero INT's, and a 118 QB rating. Yes, once again he proved he could play well in the big game. And perhaps more importantly, he was now 2-1 vs Brady when the stakes were highest, the conference championship.
So now Peyton was on his way to his 3rd Super Bowl, with his 3rd head coach. The high-powered Broncos offense would play the upstart Seahawks and their dominant defense. As is usually the case in Super Bowl history, the dominant defense would shut down the dominant offense. Little did anyone know at the time that this would be an ironic foreshadowing to the great ending of Peyton Manning's illustrious career.
The 2014 season would be another dominant one for the Broncos as they went 12-4 to win yet another division championship. But in December, Peyton had gotten hurt and it was evident down the stretch as it clearly affected his play, especially in their divisional playoff loss. After the game, it was revealed that he had indeed played the last month of the season with torn right quadriceps. How many more injuries could Manning sustain?
Then the 2015 season, which would statistically be his worst season. The injuries had played a toll as it was evident that not only his arm strength wasn't the same (primarily because of the toll of the back and neck injuries), but now he would also have a plantar fascia tear in his foot, that would require a walking boot. For the first time in his career during a season, Peyton Manning would now miss time due to injury, in favor of the young Brock Osweiler. Near the end of the season there were still questions whether or not the Broncos would even go back to playing with Manning at QB when the playoffs began since he was basically a shell of his former self physically. There was definite risk. But of course, his cerebral superiority was still fully intact and never in question. Right before the regular season finale, the Broncos had lost a crushing game to the Oakland Raiders and now the once improbable was now a possibility: would the Broncos fail to make the playoffs altogether? This was certainly a possibility as the regular season concluded vs the rival Chargers. And the game didn't start great. But then, Peyton Manning would come off the bench and lead a rally to not only save the Broncos season with a playoff berth, but simultaneously helping them clinch yet again, another #1 seed! What had been a breath away from no playoffs, now amazingly turned into the road to the Super Bowl going through Denver! Still, even after the win there was the question as to whether or not head coach Gary Kubiak would actually go with Peyton Manning as the starter in the playoffs, or stay with Brock Osweiler. Kubiak made perhaps the best decision of his coaching career, he announced Peyton Manning would indeed be the starter when the playoffs began.
In the divisional round, the Broncos trailed late and were on the verge of once again losing in their opening game. Could Peyton Manning's last game be a loss in the divisional playoffs? The Broncos were certainly on the brink but once again, Peyton led an impressive game-winning late drive to win the game and send the Broncos back to the AFC Championship game. And who would they play? None other than the New England Patriots and Tom Brady. Yes, another Manning vs Brady AFC Championship showdown. Though Peyton certainly didn't play poorly (17-32, 176 yards, 2 TD's, 0 INT's), this time, it was his defense who would carry him rather than the once dominant offenses he led. The Broncos defense pummeled Brady, and hit him more times than any QB had been hit all year. In fact, I believe it was the most Brady had been hit during any game in his career! The Broncos prevailed, sending Manning to his 4th Super Bowl, with his 4th head coach. Something no other QB in the history of the game had done. He was also taking his second team to its second Super Bowl, after taking his first team to 2 Super Bowls. Also, something no other QB in the history of the game had done. And on top of that, he was also now 3-1 vs Tom Brady in the game when the stakes were highest between the two of them- the AFC Championship game.
To sum up Super Bowl 50 vs the Carolina Panthers I will simply say, it was one of the most dominant defensive performances we have ever, and perhaps will ever see in the Super Bowl. The Broncos, and especially game MVP, Von Miller were an unbelievable wrecking crew, who reeked havoc on Cam Newton and the high-powered Panthers offense. Ironically, very similar to how Manning and his high-powered, record-setting Broncos offense was stymied by the Seahawks just two years before, once again proving: that defense wins championships.
So now, unlike many of the previous seasons where Peyton led high-powered offenses, only to suffer heartbreaking defeats where his defenses (or fluke instances as previously mentioned) essentially let his teams down, it was now his defense who would completely carry him and the offense. Though Manning did nothing to really lose the game, it was his defense who absolutely won the game. It was so fitting. Peyton Manning's last game would be a Super Bowl triumph. And he had now done something that once again no other QB in the history of the game has done: won 2 Super Bowls, with 2 different teams.
So what about the Peyton Manning legacy? What about his place on the all-time QB list? And not just in terms of greatest NFL QB's of all-time, but greatest overall QB's (college and pro) of all-time. Let me start by saying that my focus of this piece isn't to primarily make a case and seek to prove where I believe Peyton's place among the greatest QB's should be. Let me also say that this topic (greatest QB's) will always be one of the most debated, and understandably very difficult topics of discussion among sports fans, players, media, coaches, etc., because there are not only so many great players, categories, and opinions, but also the additional challenge of factoring in different era's throughout the great history of the game.
I will begin this segment by saying that I believe for anyone to make the strongest case in regards to who is the overall greatest NFL QB of all-time it would have to involve the following QB's- in no particular order: Joe Montana, Tom Brady, Johnny Unitas, John Elway, and of course, Peyton Manning.
Where do we go from here? If we begin with championships, both Tom Brady and Joe Montana have 4 apiece. And Brady has been to 6 Super Bowls.
Now for many years, I have personally considered Joe Montana the greatest QB in the history of the NFL. I had the privilege of watching him as a boy and enjoyed following his career. He played with some incredible 49ers teams, including arguably the greatest player in the history of the NFL, Jerry Rice. Yes, Montana had some very good regular seasons as his 49ers won a lot (including 2 league MVP awards), but his best moments came when the stakes were highest: the Super Bowl. Besides winning all 4 of his Super Bowls, and earning 3 Super Bowl MVP's, perhaps his most impressive stat is that he never threw an INT in the Super Bowl! Montana also had a 16-7 career record in the playoffs. And if there was ever a QB you wanted to lead a final game-winning drive with the game on the line, Montana is arguably the best ever and probably my top choice in this particular category. I think Montana's legacy was also enhanced by what he did to take the Chiefs deep into the playoffs, including the AFC Championship vs. the Bills in the '93 season.
And of course Tom Brady has his many accolades, some mentioned previously. When you combine his incredible regular season success (including 2 league MVP's), gaudy win totals with the Patriots, and 4 championships, it's very difficult to be much better than Brady. He also has 3 Super Bowl MVP's. And he boasts an NFL record, 22-9 record in the playoffs.
I believe Johnny Unitas is also in the conversation, primarily because of how he really helped transform the league from such a run-heavy league to much more of the passing league we have today. For his time period, he put up some passing numbers that were very impressive. He also led the Colts to the 1958 NFL championship, in what many call "The Greatest Game Ever Played." Though his dominant and heavily favored Colts did lose Super Bowl III in shocking fashion to the Jets, they would bounce back and win Super Bowl V vs the Cowboys. Unitas also won 3 NFL MVP's.
And then there's John Elway. Elway also had many good seasons, won 2 NFL MVP's, and also took his Broncos to 5 Super Bowls, and winning 2- his last 2 years of his amazing career. His career playoff record was 14-7. Like Montana, perhaps where Elway seemed to shine the most was when his teams had their backs against the wall and needed to pull off a comeback, late in the game. Perhaps most notably was "The Drive" vs. the Browns, in the 1986 AFC Championship. Elway was athletic and did a great job extending plays, scrambling as needed, and often making something happen off script when the play broke down.
When I look at all 5 of these great QB's, I do think a reasonable case can be made for each one not only being in this top 5 list, but perhaps a case that someone could make for each one in arguing who is "The Greatest".
And now for Peyton Manning. Now I am admittedly a little biased as you obviously know by now. While I emphatically believe Peyton is on the "Mt Rushmore" of greatest QB's ever, even in doing this tribute piece I now find myself even more convinced of where he stands among the greatest.
First off, here is what I am absolutely convinced about with Peyton Manning: He is the smartest, most prepared, and best regular season QB in NFL history. On top of this, I would now also argue (became convinced of this when working on this piece) that he is the greatest overall QB (combing college and NFL play) in history.
Next, how should we assess Peyton Manning's NFL accomplishments vs these other greats I mentioned? I will give it an attempt.
First, while stats aren't necessarily everything, they are certainly an important category to be considered as we break everything down. Here is where Peyton Manning stands:
- NFL all-time leader in passing yards (71,940).
- NFL all-time leader in TD passes (539).
- NFL all-time leader in MVP's (5).
- NFL all-time leader in passing yards for a season (5,477).
- NFL all-time leader in TD passes in a season (55).
- NFL all-time leader for most games with a perfect QB rating (4- including 1 in the playoffs).
- NFL all-time leader in most game-winning drives (56).
- NFL all-time leader in QB wins (200).
- NFL all-time QB leader (tied with Otto Graham) with 7 All-Pro awards.
- NFL record seven consecutive 12+ win seasons with Colts (8 total). And NFL QB record twelve 12+ win seasons including all 4 years with the Broncos.
- NFL record eleven 10 win seasons with Colts. And NFL QB record fifteen 10+ win seasons including all 4 years with the Broncos.
- Oldest QB in NFL history to start and win the Super Bowl.
- Only QB in NFL history to win the Super Bowl with 2 different teams.
- Only QB in NFL history to play in 4 Super Bowls- with 4 different head coaches.
- 4th all-time in completion % with 65.3%- higher than Brady (63.6%); Montana (63.2%); Elway (56.9%); and Unitas (54.6%).
But of course there are many more categories to evaluate, beyond just pure statistics. We all know that the modern day NFL is a much more pass-happy league than in years past. While a large part of this is certainly rules driven- favoring QB's in today's league more than ever- we still can't discount what generation-altering, elite QB's have done to make the league more of what it is today. One such category is the the "no-huddle" offense. And while this has been around the league for years and implemented very effectively by some of the very best QB's over time, most people would say that it was Peyton Manning who revolutionized the "no-huddle" offense, and was a master tactician at orchestrating it better than anyone who has ever played. One of Peyton's greatest strengths- that he began rapidly developing in his early UT years- was to recognize and anticipate defensive formations and schemes prior to the ball being snapped. Like many QB's who had gone before him, he would bring his teams to the line of scrimmage between plays without the typical huddle plan what to do. But in doing this, not only would he do it quickly, but with amazing calmness and seemingly not even "rushed" perfection. And then on top of this, he would often audible at the line of scrimmage as he quickly recognized something to exploit. He would also change the snap counts as a way to quickly observe how the defense would then respond. Yes, Peyton Manning would often anticipate what the defense would do before the ball was snapped. It has been said that while Manning "didn't invent the no-huddle offense, he did perfect it". He studied the game relentlessly in the film room, in books, and also in learning from one of the best, his own father, Archie. In the ESPN documentary, "The Book of Manning", one thing it talks about is how at a young age, Peyton would spend hours listening to games, and studying how various elements of the game. No doubt this early discipline and relentless pursuit of greatness would help propel him to greater heights as seasoned pro. Peyton Manning didn't just follow an offensive system he was coached in while he was QB, he pretty much ran and revolutionized his own offensive system, and succeeded incredibly with all 5 of his different NFL coaches, and 2 different teams.